Week 5: Jackie Hirai

There are many similarities between Greek and Roman, but there are specific details that make them distinct from one another. Romans admired Greek artwork. Romans learned their techniques based on Greek culture, as a result of them conquering Greece. They both used white marble to create their sculptures; however, Greek artists used more bronze compared to the Roman artists. Greek sculptures were sometimes painted by the artists because they did not like how cold the white tone of the marble can be.

The Greeks usually based their sculptures off of their gods or goddesses they worshipped like Zeus. They would amplify the sculptures’ features to make them look unreal and godly. They wanted the figure to appear youthful and strong. Greek artists studied human anatomy to figure out the right proportions they wanted to use for the best-looking sculptures. They based their sculptures’ bodies off of athletes during the time. Their athletes did not wear uniforms like ours do today. This is why Greek statues are primarily nude. The Romans made their sculptures more realistic looking without any need for enhancements. Their sculptures were based off of how the individual was seen in real life. They focused more on realism instead of idealism like Greek artists. They sculpted portraits of important people like leaders. Roman sculptures consisted of also their gods sometimes like Jupiter. Many Greek sculptures are centered around the ideas of athletics and mythology, which is different from Roman sculptures. Roman artists focused more on historical events, significant people, and their gods.

This image shows how the Greek sculpture on the left is more perfected compared to the rigid, Roman sculpture on the right:

Screen Shot 2018-07-03 at 2.08.12 PM

A famous Greek sculptor was named Phidias. He made decisions on how statues in the Pantheon would be created and the style they would be influenced by. Some of the pieces in the Pantheon are thought to be his. He created extortionary works like his gold and marble sculpture of Athena as well as Zeus, which are no longer present. The remnants of his sculptures can be seen in the British Museum. Other well-known, Greek artists include: Lysippus, Praxiteles, and Scopas. Roman sculptors copied the Greek statues, and some may say they were not imaginative; however, they were able to create some amazing originals. One of their most know statues was of the emperor, Augustus (inserted below).

Screen Shot 2018-07-03 at 2.08.05 PM

Painting and mosaics were popular type of artwork for Roman artists do create while Greek artists would paint designs more on vases and pots with watery clay to create their signature red or black figures. If they did decorate vases, Roman artists would engrave their designs that were based on naturalism. Unfortunately, a good amount of painting done by Greek artists did not survive. This is why it is hard to compare the two cultures on their styles in their paintings because we lack the evidence to do so. From the little amount of paintings preserved, it is thought that Greek artwork was centered around the ideas of harmony and simplicity compared to the extravagant style of Roman art.

Screen Shot 2018-07-03 at 2.07.56 PM

Their style in architecture was mostly different due to the type of materials they used to construct their buildings. Greeks had access to marble, so majority of their buildings consist of this element. Roman architects used concrete because they were able to obtain this substance before the Greeks. They were able to create arches and vaults due to their use of concrete and bricks. Many of the famous Roman building are made out of concrete, such as the Pantheon and Colosseum. The Parthenon and Pantheon are the most famous temples in Greece and Rome. The difference between the two was that the Greek’s Parthenon was made for Athena while the Romans’ Pantheon was made for all seven of their gods.

Roman and Greek art became intertwined resulting in their style being very similar. Their art differs in some ways and shows how even when the Romans tried to fully copy Greek art, they fell short of the standard Greek artists had set. As I researched more, I realized that even though Roman artists were influenced by Greek art, they still had originality. Roman art may not be seen as great compared to art created by Greek artists, they are both exquisite and deserved an equal amount of respect. Roman art allows us to fill in the gaps missing from the many loss pieces of Greek art.

 

Screen Shot 2018-07-03 at 2.07.42 PM

The piece of art work I decided to analyze is the Apse mosaic, “Court of Justinian”created by San Vitale in 547 A.D. It is part of a mosaic program around the alter in Ravenna, Italy. Emperor Justinian paid for these mosaics to be made. The major theme of them were to showcase the authority and power Emperor Justinian had related to the decisions for Christianity during his time as leader. In this mosaic, he is wearing a halo, crown, and a purple robe, which represent how royal and regal he was. He is accompanied by his court. Directly to his left is Archbishop Maximianus with his name above his head as well as other clergy members. Maximianus is wearing a golden cloak and has a cross with jewels in his hand possibly to represent his position in the church.

To Justinian’s right, there are court officials with their signature purple strip across their robes and soldiers. The soldiers have a shield in front of them with a symbol called the Chi-Rho used by Constantine to indicate they are the military for Christ. There are many objects in the mosaic. From Justinian’s left, there is a censer, religious text, a cross, and a bowl for the Eucharist, which is said to, “identify the mosaic as the so-called Little Entrance marking the beginning of the Byzantine liturgy of the Eucharist” (Farber, 2015). The bowl for the Eucharist is a way to signal as a tribute to the actual ruler, which is Jesus. As emperor, Justinian wanted to unify the Empire and help protect Christianity. The goal of this mosaic was to show, “Justinian as Christ’s representative on earth and to show him as worthy successor to Constantine – to express his power as head of both church and state” (Adams, 2011, p. 159). I think San Vitale achieved this idea in his mosaic.

The artist chose to use very bold and bright colors. I love the bright blue-green and red tones used through-out the border. Along with the intense color palette, the border is very detailed with light and dark shading. The mosaic is very creative and dynamic. The color choices and style of the piece represent the Hellenistic-Roman culture during this time. There is a distinct texture from the use of mosaic tiles. The gold background allows the piece to look regal and for the figures to stand out more. The facial structure and limbs of the figures are not anatomically perfect resulting in a more softer appearance to their faces and hands. There is some emotion being expressed facially, but they all appear quite solemn and/or content. This style was more about being conceptual than realistic. The artists were more focused on achieving the goal they wanted to express through their piece.

 

Resources:

Adams, L. (2011). A history of western art. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.

Guisepi, R. A. (Ed.). (2018). Greek and Roman Art. Retrieved July 01, 2018, from http://history-world.org/arthist.htm

Hemingway, C. (2007, July). Retrospective Styles in Greek and Roman Sculpture. Retrieved July 1, 2018, fromhttps://www.metmuseum.org/toah/hd/grsc/hd_grsc.htm

Hudelson, M. (2018). Greek vs. Roman Art and Architecture (Answer Key). Retrieved July 1, 2018, from https://www2.palomar.edu/users/mhudelson/StudyGuides/GreekRoman_WA.html

5 thoughts on “Week 5: Jackie Hirai”

  1. It’s kind of interesting to think about how sports uniforms have evolved into what they are today. I mean, they started out wearing hardly anything at all and now we’ve got athletes in the most elite clothing items! I love how you included the images comparing Roman to Greek face sculptures. The details are amazing. Do you happen to know who/what that baby symbolizes on the sculpture of Augustus? Is it an angel? Just curious. The mosaic that I analyzed was also part of the San Vitale program, but showed Jesus in a purple robe instead of Emperor Justinian. He also has a halo around his head like Jesus. They must’ve thought very highly of this man… Awesome analysis and blog post!

    Like

    1. I looked up what the baby on his right is. It is cupid riding a dolphin. A dolphin apparently became a symbol of Augustus’ great naval victory over Mark Antony and Cleopatra at the Battle of Actium in 31 BCE, which was a conquest that made Augustus the sole ruler of the Empire. Cupid represents how Augustus is supposed to be accented from gods. He is the son of Venus. Thanks I loved reading your blog post as well!

      Like

  2. You had a very thorough and interesting blog post! I really liked how you described the difference between Roman and Greek sculptures. It is interesting that Romans were more realistic and the Greek were more idealistic. I wonder if Romans were more practical than the Greek or they understood their human flaws better. I also love the colors in the mosaic that you choose. It is amazing how they were able to use color and shading in a mosaic with such tiny tiles!

    Like

  3. I like that you brought up Praxiteles, I was doing my curation project and I looked at a sculpture of his! I like how you point out the rigid details in the Roman sculpture compared to the Greek sculpture. I’ve noticed the bigger traits such as waist size and muscle definition, but I have never noticed how much more realistic the face is on the Roman sculpture. Do you have a preference to which style you like better?

    In addition to the golden background that helps provide the illusion of suspension, the slight difference in color surrounding the figure’s feet also add to that illusion. I think it’s interesting that they put in a lot of detail putting all the small tiles together without the intention of realism but trying to compose a conceptual piece.

    Like

    1. That is so cool that you are using one of Praxiteles’ pieces for your curation project! I was trying to figure out which style I like more when I was researching about the difference between the two. I think I like different elements of each, so I guess I like them both equally.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s